I found Sion Sono's
Suicide Club to be
borderline offensive in its use of the suicide epidemic as a
springboard for its dull detective story and bizarre red
herrings. One of my chief complaints was its seeming disinterest
in the reasons behind the phenomenon and after watching Noriko's Dinner Table, it feels
less like a companion piece to the earlier film than a correction to
that film's mistakes. The film begins with Noriko as a typically
discontent 17-year old, defined by her nervous ticks and her undying
desire to go to Tokyo to meet a mysterious poster on the Internet
discussion board she frequents. In this first of five segments,
each focusing on a different character, Sono shows Noriko as a girl who
can no longer conform to the role of happy daughter in her parent's
stagnant view of their family as she is still dragged along on inane
day trips and to her reporter father's assignments as if she were still
an
8-year old enamored with everything her father finds fascinating.
Due to this disconnect, she finds solace and a new identity in the
virtual world. Fortunately, Sono is careful not to assign blame
to
any of the characters and through each point of view, paints a complex,
contradicting individual struggling to make sense of the world once
Noriko runs away to Tokyo.
Once Noriko
makes her way to Tokyo, she assumes the identity of her Internet
moniker, Mitsuko, and meets up with fellow poster, Kumiko. Soon
after this, she becomes involved in a cult-like business that sends
people out to grieving customers looking to relieve a few hours with
dead or missing family members. We learn that Kumiko was herself
abandoned as a child and her methods veer dangerously between good
intentions and a desire to violently shake up the general trend of
bourgeois complacency. Like all of the other characters, Kumiko
is neither villain nor saint, but her conflicted relationships with her
clients and employees make her the most fascinating character to
unpackage as she's responsible for providing the film with its moral
crux. Her business is rooted in reality, yet Sono adds stylistic
flourishes and narrative unlikelihoods that place much of the film in
the realm of the metaphorical and metaphysical as well, managing the
excruciantingly difficult task of dealing with the virtual and
technological on purely human, emotional terms. Within the
company, Noriko is reunited with her sister, yet they accept each other
as Mistuko and Yoko, both as strangers with new identities and as
sisters with a silently acknowledged bond. The sociopathic
surrogacy at work in this new relationship and in the company's bizarre
method of bridging the psychological and emotional disconnection with a
simulacrum of familial normalcy is in turn destructive and
reinvigorating.
The film tacks on
another metaphorical layer with Tetsuzo's, the girl's father, search
for them. Recognizing his failure as a father, he now uses his
skills as an investigative journalist to find and repair his
relationships with his daughters. Later in the film, he uses a
friend to set up a "session" with Kumiko, Noriko and Yuka. The
two men find a house with a similar layout as Tetsuzo's and decorate
it similarly as well. Once his friend gets Kumiko to leave the
house to run some quick errands, Tetsuzo confronts the girls in this
new hyperreal battleground where their multiple identities collide as
past memories crash head on with the virtual present. Like much
that has come before it, the distinction between what is real and what
is symbolic has lost all significance as the film has become purely
about returning to an emotional and psychological equilibrium.
The confrontation fails at first both because of the amount of time
that has passed and Tetsuzo's failure to acknowledge his daughters new
identities. Their decision to remain in eternal displacement
within the cyclical surrogacy of Kumiko's company is something that
must first be acknowledged by Tetsuzo. He cannot force his
daughters to accept their former reality because a new one has replaced
it and, more importantly, was a failure in providing the girls with the
emotional sustenance they have now found in their new roles.
I will
resist spoiling whether or not Tetsuzo is successfully able to rebuild
his family and simply say the ending is a fully satisfying resolution
that manages to keep the films almost magical ability to seamlessly
shift tones and atmosphere while keeping to its own unique sense of
rhythm. Only a week earlier, I was ready to dismiss Sion Sono as
a director, but with Noriko's Dinner
Table, he proved he is able to navigate the psychological
complexities of modern youth and the older generation that struggles to
comprehend their behavior. That he does so with such stylistic
flair, full of humor and pathos, makes the film all the more satisfying
and puts Sono on the map, at least for me, as a director from whom we
can expect great things.