anna mirrorCinematic Reflections  anna mirror
A site dedicated to film appreciation


Reviews

Screening Log

Favorite Films  (Organized by Year)

Favorite Films  (Organized by Director)

Masterpieces

Links


E-mail me

 

Alphaville
Directed by Jean-Luc Godard, 1965
Rating:
by Derek Smith 10/05/03

By 1965, after only 6 short years of filmmaking, Jean-Luc Godard had established himself as one of the leading directors of the French New Wave and one of the most influential and original directors of all-time.  With Alphaville he turns the science fiction and noir genres on their sides, deconstructing and rebuilding them to his own liking and as always, for his own purposes.  Made on a shoestring budget and shot entirely in Paris with a minimal amount of set pieces, the films sci-fi feel comes from the philosophical yet witty script, Raoul Coutard's playfully dark cinematography, and the creepy monotone voice of the Alpha 60 computer.

Henri in Alphaville

The story begins with Lemmy Caution, an inter-galactic secret agent sent from the Outlands to Alphaville to find Henri Dickson, another agent from the Outlands with whom they've lost contact.  Soon after Lemmy arrives, he finds that Henri has become as sex-obsessed and mindless as the rest of Alphaville's population.  More importantly he learns that the residents are under the control of a super-computer called the Alpha 60 that bases all of its decisions on undeniably accurate logical conclusions.  Professor Vonbraun, the machines creator, is seen as a god in Alphaville with his picture hanging on almost every wall.  When the professor's daughter, Natacha Vonbraun, is assigned to look after Lemmy during his stay, he begins to realize how hopeless the citizens of Alphaville are, but for some reason senses that Natacha is different. 

anna hiding

Godard's concern in the film is not the plot although the narrative is more linear and comprehensible than many of his other films.  There are two angles that I look at this film - the political and the cinematic.  At a quick look at the plot, it may look like an Orwellian nightmare where the individual has given up all power to the government.  In a sense it is similar to Orwell's 1984, but Godard takes the nightmare to the next level and puts his own stamp on it.   One could make the arguement that Alphaville is meant to represent America (a target Godard never seems to tire of), but it really represents a way of thought where those in power rule through a system of control.  With Alphaville, he shows this system gone awry where the people no longer have any free will and the so-called logic of the system makes all the decisions.  That which is inefficient or illogical is forbidden, so there is no room for emotion, thought, or love.  In other words, as Natacha says "One must not say why but because."

When Lemmy asks Natacha about love and conscience, two words which she had never heard before, she explains that those words cannot be used because they are not in the bible.  Lemmy soon learns that what Natacha has called a bible is actually a dictionary and new editions are issued every few days forbidding more words each time.  This is simply another Godardian pun about the importance of language in shaping the conscience and the way people think.  The constant new editions show the slow progression of Alpha 60's brainwashing techniques in enforcing its own "logical" way of thinking.

The other, and much less obvious, angle of Alphaville is Godard's self-reflective views on cinema.  In successfully melding the science-fiction and noir styles without virtually any of the genres typical characteristics, it is the ultimate statement of individual creativity, something he (along with all of the other French New Wave directors) saw almost completely lacking in the films of that era.  But it is not just in the way he made Alphaville that he expresses these views, but also in the film itself.  Professor Vonbraun wears the same dark glasses that Godard himself was famous for wearing at all times.  I wouldn't say that Vonbraun represent Godard, but he does represent the typical filmmaker that is only interested in pandering to the masses rather than expresses themselves as individual artists.  The fascist system in Alphaville is as much Hollywood as it is a political system - although considering Godard sees Hollywood as a political entity in and of itself separating the two is rather pointless.

alpha ending

In the end, Alphaville comes down to a battle between the individual the state - in fact one of its alternate titles is Tarzan vs. IBM.  It is Godard's ode to free will, love, and the power of the conscience to elevate the individual to unforeseen heights.  It works both as a philosophical treatise on politics and film as well as an entertaining and often amusing look at a future overrun by technology.  The dark humor allows it to be at once ironic and prophetic while the cinematography and music set the perfect tone for the melancholic atmosphere and strange love affair between Lemmy and Natacha.  Often referred to as one of the most unconventional films ever made, Alphaville breaks all the rules creating its own cinematic reality where everything is on Godard's terms...and it works wonders.